Place purchased: Dollar Tree
Number of reviewers: 4
Appearance - 7.0
There is no paper cup! No circle of chocolate stuck to the paper!
Flavor and Taste - 8.1
The peanut butter flavor is exactly the same as a normal Butterfinger. The cups are also saltier than most other peanut butter cups.
L: OMG. So good. Creamy, salty, buttery, crunchy. Deliciousness.
S: It was better than I thought it was going to be.
Texture - 7.9
The peanut butter is mostly creamy with some mixed in crispy "peanut toffee" pieces, which seem to be tiny chunks of the flaky center inside normal Butterfingers. The added peanut toffee pieces provide a new textural consistency that works very well in these peanut butter cups.
C: I like the little crunchy pieces of Butterfinger inside.
L: Melt in your mouth with fun crunchies.
S: I liked that it still had the crunch Butterfinger pieces in it.
Aftertaste - 6.9
There is a slight peanut butter aftertaste that quickly dissipates.
L: Not bad, but nothing special. If only the taste could last forever.
S: Not much of an aftertaste, but I don't mind that.
Overall - 7.8
Overall, I think this is a great product and is definitely worth trying. Butterfinger peanut butter cups are a fantastic combination of sweet & salty and smooth & crunchy.